Writing with Structures
It's one thing to learn how to combine chords into progressions or how to fit a melody to that progression (and vice versa), but there comes a point in songwriting where you have to ask: how do I pull all these parts I've written together? You have a verse part, you have a chorus part, maybe a bridge or outro or instrumental idea. But how do you turn that into a song?
Well, this could end up being a completely inspired process. Sometimes you just know how it's all supposed to go together and the song is quickly complete. But for many of us, it's more common to have to put some real work into the process. But how do we start? One great way forward is to try some different song structures.
Bringing together the parts you've written into a song structure you're familiar with can be a great way to "test drive" the song. It may sound great as is (you're done!) or it may require some fiddling (more likely!). Let's extend that verse there, or add a new instrumental here… Or the song structure you've tried may not sound right at all. Maybe time to try a different one!
Whichever route you take, one thing is true: it's helpful to know some different song structures. Let's learn from other musicians and songwriters what can work. We'll start with a great song structure now.
Here's the brand new single from Red Hot Chili Peppers, "Black Summer."
We're going to extract the song structure and I'll walk you through the process. First we're going to do a "general listen" to figure out the different kinds of sections in the song. Then we'll dive into some detail and count out each section—a great way to really uncover some hidden gems.
The First Listen
Press play on the video and let's listen for how many different kinds of sections this song has. The song starts with an introduction. It's not very long and as we'll soon discover, it doesn't come up anywhere else. We have our first unique section.
The verse then kicks in at 0:09. Right now we're not counting how long anything is, just getting an idea for the song. As the first verse comes to a close, there's a short instrumental before the song dives back into another verse. Even though the instrumentation is really picking up in the second verse, we hear that consistent vocal melody—so it's still a verse.
Then there's something interesting. Right before the chorus kicks in at 1:34, there's a transition that really starts building the energy. That's useful to note. We'll come back to this.
Finally we're launched into the chorus. The background vocals come right in and the dynamics are big. After it wraps up, we get our first solo from Mr. Frusciante. 🙏 We can note here that it seems to be over a similar chord progression to the verse and it builds up at the end, just like the verse.
Next, the dynamics come right back down for the next verse—and it's a short one! Sounds about as quiet as the introduction, but then soon enough the chorus comes back in at full energy. No build-up this time.
Once the chorus is done, we hear something different. These kinds of "well, it's not a verse, chorus, or solo" sections are often called the "Bridge." But as it closes the song we'll call it the "Outro."
Making a map
That listen was great. We heard verses, choruses, various instrumentals/solos, and an outro. There was also an interesting extended transition before one of the verses. Now what we're going to do is make a map. This map will be the song structure that we'll store away in our memories and use as a guide in future songwriting.
We'll listen again in a moment, but this time we'll tap our foot along and count the number of bars in each section. This song, like many, has four beats to a bar, so if this is your first time doing this, it won't take long to get the hang of it. This listen will be much closer, so don't be surprised if you hear a lot more detail than last time.
Here goes:
- Intro: 4 bars
- Verse: 2 x 8 bars
- Instrumental: 4 bars
- Verse: 2 x 8 bars
- Chorus: 8 bars
- Solo: 2 x 8 bars
- Verse: 1 x 8 bars
- Chorus: 8 bars
- Outro: 16 bars
Wow, there was so much more I heard this time around (and full disclosure, I've listened to this song a lot).
Verses. Each line of the verse is 8 bars. I'm defining "line" here as a part with a distinct vocal melody. That line repeats twice for the first two verses, and just once for the third.
Build-ups. The last bar of Verse 1 really starts to pick up going into that first instrumental. They take this a step further in Verse 2 by extending that build-up by an extra bar. I put this as a one-bar transition in the map above, but it feels more like that last verse line is actually 9 bars instead of 8. Neat!
Instrumental. When tapping my foot along, I notice this section feels like 2/4 and not 4/4. In other words, each bar actually feels two beats long. Lots of chord changes. Also, I'd call this an instrumental rather than a solo because although the guitar is prominent, it's as much a rhythm part as a lead part—not entirely singable.
Vocal phrasing. The melodic phrasing in the verse, the chorus, and the solo is all 8 bars long. Very consistent.
Contrast. The third verse is very neat. The dynamics drop right off—super sparse—and instead of that build-up that happens at the end of Verse 1 and Verse 2, this verse does the opposite: near silence! Really effective way to accentuate the now-familiar chorus.
Outro. The song ends with that same Chorus energy, but everyone's doing something different so it sounds both familiar and novel. In that sense, it has an "instrumental" feel just like the first instrumental which really bookends the track nicely. The song ends with a two bar conclusion.
Back to songwriting
Now, back to our initial question: you've got your own verse, chorus, and some instrumentals—how can you fit them together? We can use maps, like the one we made above, as starting points to discover the best structure for our songs.
First, you could try a similar general structure:
I V I V C S V C O
This is a common structure and for good reason. Maybe you'll shorten Verse 3 like in Black Summer or maybe not. It's a great one to start test-driving your ideas with.
Second, you could use a similar strategy for transitions. In other words, you could really build at the end of Verse 1, then build-up again—maybe with that one extra bar—at the end of Verse 2, and then do the opposite and drop to near-silence at the end of Verse 3.
Third, if you're still working out your verse and chorus parts, you could try for consistent phrase lengths just like in Black Summer. Maybe that's 8 bars every time. Or maybe shorter/longer.
In any case, this is the beauty of studying the music we love. We get to understand it more and we get to pull out tools we can use in our own songwriting. Hope you enjoyed this post. Feedback welcome.
–Alex (maker of Waay)
Submitted April 29, 2022 at 12:17PM by alex_TK https://www.reddit.com/r/Learnmusic/comments/ueo6ru/songwriting_and_song_structures_a_deepdive_into/?utm_source=ifttt